SI
Shelter Island Sand Gravel & Construction0 mi
17 Bowditch Rd, Shelter Island, NY
Landfills, dumps and drop-offs near Shelter Island, NY
50 landfills, transfer stations and recyclers within 25 miles of Shelter Island, NY. Filter by what you need to get rid of.
50 facilitiesUpdated October 2026Source: the US EPA Disaster Debris Recovery Tool
Facilities come from the US EPA Disaster Debris Recovery Tool. Accepted materials, fees and residency rules change, so call the facility before you load up.
50 facilities near Shelter Island, NY
SI
Shelter Island Recycling Transfer Station0 mi
34 N Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY
MM
Marcello Masonry0 mi
67 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
ST
Southold Town Transfer Station8 mi
6155 Cox Lane, Cutchogue, NY
CA
Corazzini Asphalt Inc8 mi
6245 Cox Ln, Cutchogue, NY
SS
Sagaponack Sand & Gravel Corp9 mi
32 Haines Path, Bridgehampton, NY
CM
Cutchogue Materials and Recycling9 mi
350 Commerce Dr, Cutchogue, NY
NS
North Sea Landfill & Transfer Station10 mi
1370 Majors Path, North Sea, NY
BG
Bistrian Gravel Corp11 mi
225 Spring Fireplace Rd., East Hampton, NY
BM
Bistrian Materials Inc-East Hampton11 mi
175 Springs-Fireplace Rd, East Hampton, NY
EN
Emil Norsic & Son Inc12 mi
42 Sandy Hollow Rd, Southampton, NY
SM
Steven M Mezynieski12 mi
110 N Magee St, Southampton, NY
DA
Delalio Asphalt12 mi
224 N Main St, Southampton, NY
LI
Long Island Compost Farm #35a13 mi
1 Old Riverhead Moriches Road (off Cr 51), Southampton, NY
HH
Half Hollow Nursery13 mi
2120 Main Road, Laurel, NY
HB
Hampton Bays Transfer Station (landfill Site)16 mi
30 Jackson Avenue, Hampton Bays, NY
WT
Westbrook Transfer Station17 mi
154 McVeagh Road, Westbrook, CT
OS
Old Saybrook Transfer Station17 mi
Middlesex Turnpike, Old Saybrook, CT
BF
Briermere Farms18 mi
4414 Sound Ave, Riverhead, NY
OL
Old Lyme Transfer Station18 mi
30 Short Hills Road, Old Lyme, CT
CT
Clinton Transfer Station19 mi
117 Old Nod Road, Clinton, CT
EC
East Coast Mines19 mi
41 Lewis Rd, East Quogue, NY
EL
East Lyme Transfer Station20 mi
91 Roxbury Road, East Lyme, CT
BM
Bistrian Materials Inc-Montauk20 mi
86 Industrial Rd, Montauk, NY
HA
Horton Avenue Materials20 mi
229 Horton Ave, Riverhead, NY
QH
Quogue - Highway Yard21 mi
40 Old Country Road, Quogue, NY
CR
Crown Recycling Facility21 mi
865 Youngs Ave, Riverhead, NY
RY
Riverhead Yardwaste Facility21 mi
532 Youngs Ave., Calverton, NY
FI
Fishers Island Wmd Transfer Station and Compost Facility21 mi
2660 Whistler Avenue, Fishers Island, NY
ET
Eastern Transfer Station, LLC21 mi
400 Commercial Drive, Deep River, CT
YA
Youngs Ave. Landfill Compost Site22 mi
Youngs Ave., Riverhead, NY
CA
Chesterfield Associates23 mi
56 S Country Rd, West Hampton Beach, NY
SA
Suffolk Asphalt Supply-West Hampton Beach23 mi
100 Rogers Ave, West Hampton Beach, NY
CT
Chester Transfer Station23 mi
220 Winthrop Road, Chester, CT
TH
Ts Haulers24 mi
3968 Middle Country Rd, Calverton, NY
WT
Westhampton Transfer Station24 mi
66 Old Country Road, Westhampton, NY
GM
Green Meadows LLC24 mi
4083 Middle Country Rd, Calverton, NY
LI
Long Island Compost Farm #3024 mi
Speonk-Riverhead Road (between Sunrise Hwy and Evergreen), Westhampton, NY
WP
Westhampton Property Associates Inc24 mi
1220 Speonk-Riverhead Rd, Speonk, NY
KT
Killingworth Transfer Station24 mi
Recycle Way, Killingworth, CT
JT
John T Montecalvo Inc24 mi
1217 Spenok - Riverhead Rd, Speonk, NY
LT
Lyme Transfer Station24 mi
Brush Hill Road, Lyme, CT
SE
Speonk Earth Recycling LLC24 mi
60 5th Ave, Speonk, NY
NL
New London Transfer Station24 mi
63 Lewis Street, New London, CT
SM
Sky Materials Corp.24 mi
4331 Middle Country Road, Calverton, NY
GM
Guilford/madison Transfer Station25 mi
1900 Boston Post Road, Guilford, CT
SS
Suburban Sanitation Inc7 mi
92 Clay Pit Rd, Sag Harbor, NY
EH
East Hampton Recycling Center11 mi
260 Springs Fireplace Road, East Hampton, NY
ET
Essex Transfer Station20 mi
Town Dump Road, Essex, CT
CR
Calamari Recycling Co. Inc.21 mi
20 Town Dump Rd, Essex, CT
Rather not haul it yourself near Shelter Island, NY?
Tell us what needs to go and get a quote from a local junk removal or dumpster company.
Free, no obligation. We never sell your details.
Run one of these businesses? Claim your listing, add a missing one or get featured in Shelter Island, NY.
Disposal guides by material
Common questions
Where is the closest dump to Shelter Island, NY?
The facilities above are sorted by distance from Shelter Island, NY. Transfer stations are often the closest drop-off for residents.
Where can I take treated wood near Shelter Island, NY?
Look for landfills and transfer stations in the list and call to confirm they accept treated wood from residents.